Skip to content
Games/Conversation
Conversation · Traditional game

Desert Island Picks

Everyone secretly writes three things they'd take to a desert island. Then guess who wrote each list.

Time
20 min
Players
4–15
Ages
6+ · 13+ · Adults
You need
paper and pens
The goal

Guess who wrote each list, and make your own list hard to guess.

Video © 2026 Kinnected.
1

Get ready

  1. Pick one person to be the host. The host reads the lists out.
  2. Everyone gets a piece of paper and a pen.
  3. Imagine you're stuck on a desert island. Secretly write down three things you'd take. No boats or phones, because they'd help you leave!
  4. Fold your paper and give it to the host. On a video call, send your list to the host in a private message.
2

How to play

  1. The host mixes up the papers and reads one list out loud.
  2. Everyone guesses who wrote it. You can say your guess or write it down.
  3. The person who wrote it puts their hand up and says why they picked one of their things.
  4. Then the host reads the next list. Keep going until every list has been read.
3

Scoring

  • You get 1 point for each list you guess right.
  • When it's your list, you get 1 point for every person who guessed wrong.
When every list has been read, whoever has the most points wins.
4

Example rounds

What a real round looks like.

Example 1

One list, 6 players

  1. The host reads: "A guitar, a hammock and 500 tea bags."
  2. Four people guess it was Joe. One person guesses Mei.
  3. It was Mei! She says: "I can't live without tea."
  4. The one person who guessed Mei gets 1 point.
  5. Mei tricked four people, so Mei gets 4 points.

Host tips

  • Keep it kind. The fun is in the surprise, not in teasing.

Did you play it?

Traditional gameTraditional party game. Rules, scoring and examples written by Kinnected. Text © 2026 Kinnected. Character art © 2026 Kinnected. Free to use with your own group; commercial reuse needs a licence.

Keep score